Male Headship 1—A Young Girl’s Perspective

It was just before my sixth birthday when my Mom took me school shopping for the first time. As we went from store to store, I tried on dresses while she adjusted the collars, then she had me twirl around so she could look at all sides of me. I reveled in her attention because we’d had very little quality time since my youngest sister’s birth six months before.

When we got home, Mommy suggested I put on my new dresses and have a fashion show for Daddy. I ran to my room full of excitement to be the center of my parents’ attention. I threw on one of my new plaid dresses not bothering to take off the tags, but carefully adjusting the collar just like Mommy had shown me.

I ran back out to the living room and twirled around—until my eye caught a look of disappointment on Daddy’s face. As I turned to look at him, his eyes fell to the floor and he cleared his throat, then he turned to Mommy and with a disappointed voice asked, “Why are you dressing her in men’s clothes?”

Mommy said they weren’t men’s clothes–they were plaid dresses which was what all the little girls were wearing in 1969. Daddy asked if she could take the clothes back. Mommy said it wouldn’t matter because it was the only style in the stores at the time.

As they continued to argue about my new clothes, I lowered my head and slunk back to my room. There was no use in trying on another dress, everything we bought—including my lunchbox was plaid.

I Am My Own Person Tote, CherilynClough.com LittleRedSurvivor.com

This was my first experience with male headship. No one called it that, but I picked up on several things in this encounter.

1. It is Wrong to Dress Like a Man in any way
As I grew older I was told that long hair was given to a woman for a covering and it was wrong to cut it. I was not allowed to wear jeans because they were men’s clothing and it would be a dishonor to God for me to dress like a man. I once started to hand my brother a purple towel, but I was told not to give him purple. This confused me.

While I was not to dress like a boy, I was also not encouraged to wear many girly things because they fit under the category of vanity. All nail polish, makeup and jewelry were forbidden. I was once threatened with belting for wearing tinted chapstick. I was told it was inappropriate to show skin or swim with boys and  I was taught that what I wore might cause some boy to sin, so I had to be modest at all times. My parents read and followed a little book called Creeping Compromise which was about the evils of external behavior.

2. Men Are Superior and Always in Charge Except for the Kitchen
It’s a man’s world but women are given a supporting role. Men get to make the rules and decide what you wear and if they don’t like it, they can make you take it back. This issue of being in charge went beyond clothing. It covered just about any part of my life. It meant that food must be ready the minute my dad came in the door. That if he was in a bad mood, I had to tiptoe on eggshells and do whatever he wanted or I would be belted. Sometimes it seems I was belted just because he was in a bad mood. When I was small, my mom used to say she hated it when my dad punished me in anger, but she didn’t stand up for me because they were a team and had agreed to remain in agreement even when they weren’t.

When it came to music, we could only listen to music if my father approved it or he was in a good mood. In order to keep control of me, my parents decided to keep me out of school to protect me from getting contaminated by the world. Basically I stayed home and worked as their slave for most of my teen years. From an early age I was expected to bake six loaves of bread every week, do a large portion of the housework, cook large meals for a family of six and babysit my siblings.

3. Women Are Not as Smart or as Spiritual as Men
I knew this was true because my mom never did anything that my dad did not want her to do. She deferred to him in everything except cooking and cleaning. In that realm she was in charge, but she still had to have supper ready when he was ready to eat.  Everything in our home rotated around my father’s moods. While we were not a quivering family, my parents’ had specific expectations for women and they did not include me learning to be independent.

The weird thing was that my father once told me that he felt bad because his mother never learned to drive, so he said he wanted me to learn to drive and have a way to make a living, but somewhere between this idea and reality he never taught me to drive nor found a way to help me go to school. Another time he told me if my husband ever asked me what I wanted to do to have an idea and not act passive. I got the idea from both of my parents that my opinion mattered—but only as long as it agreed with theirs.

It’s the saddest mystery in my life that my father actually tried to encourage me to be a strong woman, but then told me not to be like other strong women we met. When a woman showed leadership, my parents said she wore the pants in the family. If a woman did not have children, she was called selfish. If the pastor’s wife worked for a living, she was called worldly and material minded. The women we met were none of these things, but to a young girl this made an impression that I had no right to do anything but be a housewife and please my husband.

Nowhere was this idea of men in charge more obvious than when it came to what we believed about God. My mom taught me to trust God and obey and I will always have a special place in my heart for her loving ways of teaching me about Jesus as a small child. As I got older, my dad was the only one in charge of worship and then only if he was in the mood.

My maternal grandmother was a Bible worker who brought nearly a hundred people into the church in her lifetime, but my father never agreed with her about God. If Grandma began to teach me something she was reading about, it almost always guaranteed that my dad would end up in an argument with her. When we drove away, he would say she never went to theology school and didn’t know what she was talking about. It wasn’t until I was in my forties that I discovered my grandmother had a much better picture of God than I had grown up with. She was powerless to speak to me much about it, but she tried to give me the crumbs under the table.

The place my father’s control affected my life the most after the spiritual expectations was my education. School was never a priority for my dad and he didn’t see it as one for me. I was told to tell people at church I was being homeschooled, but they never bought the books. If I asked for books and complained about not keeping up with kids my age, I was called spoiled and selfish.

When I finally went to college, I had few career choices that seemed acceptable to my family. My interests included psychology which was considered evil, becoming a pastor which was out because my father had tried to talk me out of attending the Christian University I chose because they had a woman preacher. And there was no way I could consider anything in the medical field because I had never had science since the sixth grade. It seems that from my father’s perspective, my obvious career choices we just as inappropriate as those plaid dresses he wanted my mother to take back. Because I was so unprepared, college turned out to be a very confusing and depressing time in my life.

If I gave the impression my father did not love me, that’s not true, but there was this dichotomy between his words and his behavior. My mother contributed to my role expectations too because she told me in third grade that my mind was not made for math like hers. This sort of headship mindset really confuses a girl and makes her wonder if she can be good at anything besides cooking and cleaning.

While I am not angry about my childhood at all, I certainly had to reframe events so I could heal from it. This blog has explained the perspective of male headship from my own childhood and teen perspective, but others have had a much more brutal treatment. I don’t believe that what I experienced is the norm. Many children who grow up with male headship struggle in different ways. If you are one of those, please feel free to share your experience with me, I would love to hear your story.

In my next blog I will discuss why I believe male headship is NOT God’s plan.

Did you grow up with different rules and expectations for girls and boys? How does it affect your life today? 

6 Replies to “Male Headship 1—A Young Girl’s Perspective”

  1. Hi Cheryl,

    I really appreciate your site & blog, your insight into the dynamics and effects of parental narcissism, your sharing and your encouragement to those who have suffered from it. I have often marveled that somebody who has no formal degrees can have such a better understanding of these things than people who’ve studied & written books about it do.

    I would appreciate it if you would precisely define male headship in your next post before you explain why you don’t believe it is God’s plan. Just for the sake of clarity.

    Also, I thought I heard you say recently that there is no hell, or that nobody goes to hell? Or maybe you said God doesn’t send people there? I was not sure.

    I’m not trying to be confrontational, I just want to be clear on where you’re coming from.

    Thanks,

    Jim

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you Jim for your compliment. I appreciate your polite questions and yes, I will be talking about what I believe male headship entails–although there are various interpretations and mine may not match yours or someone else’s.

    When it comes to the topic of hell, I do not believe in everlasting hell. Many scholars have shown that this is a misunderstanding and if the scriptures are studied in their entirety we find that the scriptures speak of Gehenna–a garbage dump that was always burning because people took all their junk there to burn it. That said, I am not a universalist, I do believe the wicked will be destroyed by the presence of God–not because God uses revenge on them, but because they have chosen by their own free will to rebel against God’s law of other-centered love. If we chose NOT to be in harmony with our Life-giver we will not survive God’s presence. There are many scriptures I could use to explain this and if this is a concern of yours, I would be happy to reply to a private email if you want to write me at CherilynClough@live.com I am not trying to hide what I believe, I think it is obvious throughout my blogging for the last seven years, but such conversations are lengthy. May you find peace in our Heavenly Parent!

    Like

  3. Thanks for the clarification Cheryl,

    I haven’t been reading your blog long enough enough to have picked that up.

    It kind of sounds like annihilationism along the lines of what John Stott believed, whose book “The Cross of Christ” is probably my favorite book of all time.

    I respect both him and you a lot.

    We don’t agree on this issue, but… that will have to be OK. 🙂

    thanks,

    Jim

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Thank you for the respect. I want to always respect people even when we disagree. I think we can only honor our God if we show respect to all of His children–even His rude and wayward children. 🙂

    Yes, I think annihilation is the word, at the same time, I firmly believe that this annihilation is not the direct revenge of God, but rather His letting his children go who have chosen to be disconnected from Him. To see it from this perspective, one would have to understand that the soul is not immortal, but that we will be given immortal life when Jesus comes. Now I have probably really confused you. Like I said this could take a lot of words. 🙂

    Like

  5. What you said makes sense to me, I can see that, God lets people endure the consequences of their choices. Still don’t agree totally about the no hell, but like you said, that would be a long conversation, and even then we might not agree.

    I don’t know if you’re in the process of obtaining some kind of degree that will enable you to be a licensed counselor, but my two cents is that you would likely be really good and help a lot of people. Just wanted to encourage you about that.

    Like

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s